Medieval History
Recently, there's been some traffic on an older post of mine about the American soldier wearing his militum Christi arm patch. "Mike" had some interesting thoughts that I wanted to share. My response is below his:
- On "just War": Understanding Pres. Barack Obama And His Nobel Speech
Augustine of Hippo, by Botticelli UPDATED (now with more paper): An edited version of this post has now appeared in The Roanoke Times. ----- Today, Pres. Barack Obama formally received his Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo, Norway. The committee...
- Blogging And Learning: Why Study The Middle Ages
In response to some of the posts that have recently been put up, I received this in an email from a former student (Garrick Bjur). I share it, with his permission, in its entirety. I enjoy how your blog, as you said, continually looks at how...
- Revisiting The Crusades (with Or Without A Degree)
So, bear with me here. This is going to be a long post, but I think it's going somewhere... On 12/10/08, in The Roanoke Times, a local resident (in response to Gov. Tim Kaine's tacit support of the Virginia State Police superindendant's decision...
- Chapters
Tonight, President Obama declared the end of the combat mission in Iraq. I had three months to go in my pregnancy with Mister O when this war started, one of the longest wars this country has ever fought (we'd say the longest, but it's hard...
- Mines On Your Mind - The Mes Aynak Copper Mine
In Logar province, Afghanistan, approximately 25 miles south of Kabul lays Mes Aynak, an ancient Buddhist city doomed to vanish forever under a project touted as a magic bullet for the war torn economy of Afghanistan. It's ancient streets and buildings...
Medieval History
Dialogue on Military Arm Patches
Recently, there's been some traffic on an older post of mine about the American soldier wearing his militum Christi arm patch. "Mike" had some interesting thoughts that I wanted to share. My response is below his:Matthew, have you ever been to Afghanistan? If not why are you contending a statement I made based on what I've seen in this country since the war started. Christians were prosecuted just as much as Muslims were in the Crusades so even if it would offend Muslims, why should we care? Also, I didn't say they can't read because I'm naive. I said it because they really can't read. Unless they were educated in Kabul (about 1% of the country's population) they can't read anything. They don't even know what year it is or their own age most of the time. I'm not naive at all, I know for a fact 95% of them can't read because I'm in Afghan villages 2-3 times per week. Besides that, I work alongside Afghan Commandos mainly, but also ANA and ANCOP and ANSF. They are not offended by patches such as the one in the picture. Most of them don't even know what it means and don't know who the Templar Knights even were.My response:
You are right, the Taliban and similar terrorist organizations are very tech savvy. But only because the stuff is given to them by bigger players and they are taught how to use it. Terrorist training camps don't teach about how to read and the Crusades, they teach how to kill people.
I didn't chime in here to have a big internet argument, I just think all these negative comments about the soldier wearing the patch are completely irrelevant. I'm sure most of you have never been to any Muslim 3rd world country, let alone Afghanistan. Yet you make these statements like you can read people's minds and know how they would react to some things. You have no understanding whatsoever of how these people think and live their daily lives. If you base your statements on the news or anything you read on the internet you're wrong. Unless you have firsthand experience in this country, and I don't mean never leaving the FOB, there's no point in arguing.
One more thing, as I see you have a PhD in history. Obviously you have a much greater scope of knowledge of the Crusades than probably anybody else that posts here. I'm also sure you've been taught a great deal about religious wars and the history of Islam and Islamic nations. However, when people such as yourself refer to 'Islamic understandings of the Crusades since the 19th century' Afghanistan doesn't really fit into that. Almost every generic reference to Islamic nations in more recent history is based on developed locations that actually have an education system in place and have contact with the rest of the world. Afghanistan doesn't quite fit into there. I can't speak for Iraq as I have much less experience in that country. But these people really don't know much of anything in Afghanistan besides farming. Sure they have some technologies from the bigger cities like Kabul and some from Khandahar, but nothing you could even remotely call advanced. Their technology doesn't go beyond old crappy cars and tracfones. They don't have electricity in their homes. Their homes are made of mud and feces. They poop in their home right on the floor and it just stays there until flies eat it. These people have bigger problems and concerns than what our patches say. They really couldn't care less. The patch that soldier is wearing is not a big deal, no reason to make it a big deal.
On a side note: Some Air Force actual unit patches refer to the Crusades or Templar Knights.
Mike, thanks again for coming back and thanks for these thoughtful comments. I don't (totally) disagree with what you're saying. Personally, and given my own research interests, I'm more interested in what this says about some (not universal) American attitudes towards wars against radical Islamic groups.Mike's right too, of course, that I don't have experience in Afghanistan and he's clearly more informed about the situation on the ground. That said, the ideas that animate this conflict can be said to be more cultural than literate (if that makes sense). Ideas move even in pre-literate societies and I know something about that, having studied the European Middle Ages. For example, Afghanis by and large may not be able to read, haven't read Edward Said, and have no idea what militum Christi means, but my guess is that they "understand" (not objectively, but based on their own cultural assumptions) an American showing up in their village wearing a cross on his arm.
Framing the conflict - in any way - as "Christian" against "Muslim" moves the level to a different, troubling level. For example, how does a war between "Christian" and "Muslim" end? With the elimination of the other, either by death, conversion, or subjugation? How does a "war against terror" end? It can't -- at least not in this lifetime -- because there will always be those who seek political/ social power through violence against innocents. The only way to "square this circle" is through an apocalyptic, zero-sum war in which there's only 1 winner and 1 loser. That means that all Muslims, everywhere, are on 1 side and all Christians, everywhere, are on the other. But that's not useful. We're fighting the Taliban, Al Qaeda, Al Shabab, etc. -- just like the many peaceful inhabitants of Afghanistan, Pakistan, Somalia, etc. are as well. Ultimately, you're certainly right on your last point (that Afghanis have bigger problems than American arm patches) but I'm wondering about us. Do some of us have bigger problems too or is this THE problem we have?
I have much more to say and I realize that this brief comment doesn't do justice to your longer one above. Hopefully, this dialogue will continue.
- On "just War": Understanding Pres. Barack Obama And His Nobel Speech
Augustine of Hippo, by Botticelli UPDATED (now with more paper): An edited version of this post has now appeared in The Roanoke Times. ----- Today, Pres. Barack Obama formally received his Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo, Norway. The committee...
- Blogging And Learning: Why Study The Middle Ages
In response to some of the posts that have recently been put up, I received this in an email from a former student (Garrick Bjur). I share it, with his permission, in its entirety. I enjoy how your blog, as you said, continually looks at how...
- Revisiting The Crusades (with Or Without A Degree)
So, bear with me here. This is going to be a long post, but I think it's going somewhere... On 12/10/08, in The Roanoke Times, a local resident (in response to Gov. Tim Kaine's tacit support of the Virginia State Police superindendant's decision...
- Chapters
Tonight, President Obama declared the end of the combat mission in Iraq. I had three months to go in my pregnancy with Mister O when this war started, one of the longest wars this country has ever fought (we'd say the longest, but it's hard...
- Mines On Your Mind - The Mes Aynak Copper Mine
In Logar province, Afghanistan, approximately 25 miles south of Kabul lays Mes Aynak, an ancient Buddhist city doomed to vanish forever under a project touted as a magic bullet for the war torn economy of Afghanistan. It's ancient streets and buildings...